Blog /
Finance & Tax

Paid Twice or Paid an Excess Charge? Recovering Money Under Section 72 of the Contract Act

Home buyers sometimes pay the same dues twice, pay the wrong party, or pay a charge they dispute to avoid delay. Section 72 of the Indian Contract Act says a person to whom money is paid by mistake or under coercion must repay it, and its illustrations cover both duplicate payments and illegally excessive charges.

Finance & Tax
Updated on
November 18, 2026
12 min read

A new owner sets up an auto-debit for association maintenance, and the seller, who has not yet cancelled theirs, pays the same quarter. A buyer pays a builder's demand for an extra charge because the keys will not be released otherwise, and only later reads that the agreement never mentioned it. A family pays a contractor's advance into what turns out to be the wrong account. In each case the question is the same: can the money be recovered, and on what basis?

The Indian Contract Act, 1872 answers in a single sentence, Section 72, supported by two illustrations that fit home buying surprisingly well. This guide explains it, along with Section 70, in the Act's own words. It is buyer guidance, not legal advice; specific forums such as RERA may also apply where a builder is involved.

The short answer. Section 72 of the Indian Contract Act says a person to whom money has been paid, or anything delivered, by mistake or under coercion, must repay or return it. Its illustrations say a creditor paid twice by two joint debtors must repay the second payment, and a person who pays an illegal charge to obtain goods can recover so much of it as was illegally excessive. The trade-off: the law supports recovery, but you still have to prove the mistake or the excess, so a written objection at the time of payment and clean records make the difference between a refund and an argument.

What does Section 72 actually say?

Its heading is liability of person to whom money is paid, or thing delivered, by mistake or under coercion. The text is short: a person to whom money has been paid, or anything delivered, by mistake or under coercion, must repay or return it.

Two features matter for buyers. First, it covers money and things, so it can apply to a payment, a deposit or a document handed over by mistake. Second, it covers two different situations: payment by mistake, and payment under coercion. The section does not ask whose fault the mistake was, only whether the money was paid by mistake. The illustrations show one of each.

SituationWhat the Contract Act saysWhat a buyer should keep
Same dues paid twiceSection 72, illustration (a): the recipient must repay the second paymentProof of both payments and dates
Payment to the wrong personSection 72: money paid by mistake must be repaidBank record showing the transfer and the intended payee
Excess charge paid to obtain somethingSection 72, illustration (b): the illegally excessive part is recoverableA written objection made at the time of payment
Work or goods delivered, not as a giftSection 70: the person who enjoys the benefit must compensate or restoreEvidence that the work was not intended to be free
Builder's charge not in the agreementThe RERA route may also apply alongside the Contract ActYour agreement for sale and the demand letter

I paid the same dues twice. Can I get the second payment back?

The first illustration is almost exactly this case. A and B jointly owe 100 rupees to C. A alone pays the amount to C, and B, not knowing this, pays 100 rupees over again. The illustration says C is bound to repay the amount to B.

In a property handover, duplicate payments can arise when a buyer and seller both pay the same maintenance, utility or tax demand for an overlapping period. The recipient holds money it was not owed. Write to the recipient with proof of both payments and ask for the duplicate to be refunded. As a simple illustration, if the quarterly maintenance is Rs 9,000 and both buyer and seller pay it for the same quarter, the association has received Rs 18,000 for a Rs 9,000 demand, and the second Rs 9,000 is the amount to ask for. The figures are hypothetical; the logic is the illustration's. Where the payment was made through an official portal, follow its grievance process; our guide to Bengaluru property tax for 2026-27 explains how the city portal handles duplicate payments.

What if I paid a charge I dispute, just to get the keys?

The second illustration is about precisely that pressure. A railway company refuses to deliver goods to the consignee except on payment of an illegal charge for carriage. The consignee pays the sum to obtain the goods. The illustration says the consignee is entitled to recover so much of the charge as was illegally excessive.

The structure is the important part: the payment was made to obtain something the payer was entitled to, and the part that was illegally excessive is recoverable. Whether a charge you paid was in fact excessive depends on your agreement and the law, so the illustration is a guide to the principle, not a promise of a refund. What it does show is why you should record your objection when you pay. A short written note saying you are paying under protest, to obtain possession, and reserving your right to recover the disputed amount, preserves your position. Our report on a disputed extra demand before handover shows how such disputes reach a regulator.

Does it matter whether the payee was a builder?

It can add a route. Where the payee is a promoter under the RERA Act and the dispute concerns charges under an agreement for sale, the RERA authority may also be relevant, alongside the general principle in Section 72. For a resale purchase between individuals, or a payment to a contractor or association, Section 72 is the general rule to start from, and it does not depend on the payee being a builder or a regulated entity of any kind. In either case, the evidence you need is the same: what you paid, to whom, when, and why it was not owed.

What about work done that someone else benefits from?

Section 70 covers a related situation. It says that where a person lawfully does anything for another person, or delivers anything to him, not intending to do so gratuitously, and such other person enjoys the benefit thereof, the latter is bound to make compensation to the former in respect of, or to restore, the thing so done or delivered.

Its illustrations draw the line. A tradesman who leaves goods at B's house by mistake, which B treats as his own, must be paid for them. But a person who saves another's property from fire is not entitled to compensation if the circumstances show the act was meant to be gratuitous. For a buyer, Section 70 can be relevant where you paid for repairs or improvements that end up benefiting a seller or neighbour, but only if it is clear you did not intend them as a favour.

How do I improve my chances of getting money back?

Make the mistake or the objection visible at the time. Section 72 states the obligation, but the facts still have to be shown. A payment made under protest, with a dated note, is far easier to recover than one made silently and disputed months later. Duplicate payments are easier to prove when both receipts are kept together.

Act promptly once you notice the problem. Write to the recipient, explain why the money was not owed, attach proof, and ask for repayment by a reasonable date. If the recipient refuses, take advice on the appropriate forum for the amount and the type of payee.

A good refund request is short and specific. It identifies the payment by date, amount and reference number, explains in one or two sentences why it was not owed, attaches the receipts, names the account to which the refund should be sent, and gives a date by which you expect a reply. Keep a copy of the request and of any acknowledgement. If the matter later goes to a forum, that letter becomes part of your evidence that you raised the issue promptly.

What should a Bengaluru buyer do before and after paying?

Whether the payment relates to a flat in a project such as Sobha Victoria Park on Hennur Main Road or to a resale handover, the same habits help.

  1. Check every demand against your agreement before paying, and ask for the clause that supports it.
  2. Coordinate with the seller on who pays which dues for the handover period, in writing.
  3. Keep receipts and bank records for every payment in one file.
  4. If you must pay a disputed charge to obtain possession or documents, write that you pay under protest.
  5. When you spot a duplicate or wrong payment, write to the recipient promptly with proof.
  6. Ask for repayment by a stated date, citing the mistake or the excess.
  7. If a builder refuses, consider whether the RERA route applies alongside Section 72, and take advice.

Frequently asked questions

What does Section 72 of the Contract Act say?

Section 72 of the Indian Contract Act says a person to whom money has been paid, or anything delivered, by mistake or under coercion, must repay or return it. Its illustrations cover a debt paid twice by two joint debtors and an illegal charge paid to obtain goods, of which the illegally excessive part is recoverable.

I paid the same maintenance or dues twice. Can I get it back?

Section 72's first illustration describes two joint debtors who owe 100 rupees; one pays, and the other, not knowing, pays again. The creditor is bound to repay the second payment. Raise a written refund request with the recipient, attaching proof of both payments.

Can I recover an excess charge I paid to get possession?

Section 72's second illustration describes a consignee who pays an illegal charge to get goods released and is entitled to recover so much of the charge as was illegally excessive. Whether a charge you paid was excessive depends on your agreement and the law, so record your objection when you pay.

What if someone benefits from work I paid for by mistake?

Section 70 of the Indian Contract Act says that where a person lawfully does anything for another or delivers anything to him, not intending to do so gratuitously, and the other enjoys the benefit, the latter must compensate the former or restore the thing done or delivered.

Last updated 2026-11-18. PropNewz Team.

Contact Us

Stay updated with latest news and new projects!

Thank you! Your submission has been received, We'll get back in touch with you shortly.
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
No pressure, ever

Tell us what you want, We'll do the rest.

Share your budget and where you're looking. An advisor who has actually walked the sites will shortlist a handful of RERA-registered projects and tell you which to skip.

We only contact you about projects you ask about
No spam, no reselling your number, unsubscribe anytime
Independent advice we're paid the same whoever you pick
Thank you! Your submission has been received, We'll get back in touch with you shortly.
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.