Who Goes First on Registration Day? Balance Payment, Signature and the Law on Reciprocal Promises
On registration day, buyers and sellers sometimes stall over who moves first: the balance payment or the signature on the sale deed. The Contract Act's rules on reciprocal promises and tender of performance, read with Section 55 of the Transfer of Property Act, give a clear framework. How Bengaluru buyers can protect themselves.
The sub-registrar's office is booked for 11 am. The buyer's bank has issued a demand draft for the balance. The seller has the original deeds in a folder. And then, at the counter, nobody wants to move first. The seller will not sign until the money is in hand; the buyer will not hand over the draft until the deed is signed. It sounds like a small standoff, but it can unravel a deal that took months to put together.
The law has a framework for exactly this moment. The Indian Contract Act, 1872 has rules on reciprocal promises and on offering to perform, and the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 sets out what buyer and seller are each bound to do when a sale is completed. This guide explains both, in the Acts' own words. It is buyer guidance, not legal advice.
The short answer. Section 51 of the Indian Contract Act says that where reciprocal promises are to be performed simultaneously, no promisor need perform unless the other is ready and willing to perform. Section 55(1)(d) of the Transfer of Property Act ties the seller's duty to execute the conveyance to payment or tender of the price, and Section 55(5)(b) requires the buyer to pay or tender at the time and place of completing the sale. The trade-off: insisting on strict simultaneity protects you from paying without a deed, but it only works if your agreement spells out the order and you can show you were ready and willing.
What is a reciprocal promise, and why does it matter at registration?
A sale agreement is built on promises that answer each other. The seller promises to execute the sale deed; the buyer promises to pay the balance. Section 51 deals with promises meant to happen together. It says that when a contract consists of reciprocal promises to be simultaneously performed, no promisor need perform his promise unless the promisee is ready and willing to perform his reciprocal promise.
Its illustration is a simple sale of goods. A and B contract that A shall deliver goods to B, to be paid for on delivery. A need not deliver unless B is ready and willing to pay on delivery, and B need not pay unless A is ready and willing to deliver on payment. Replace the goods with a signed sale deed and the payment with the balance consideration, and you have the registration-day standoff, with the Act's answer: each side is entitled to see that the other is ready.
| Provision | What it says | What it means on registration day |
|---|---|---|
| Contract Act, Section 51 | No promisor need perform a simultaneous promise unless the other is ready and willing | Each side can insist on seeing the other is ready |
| Contract Act, Section 52 | Promises are performed in the order the contract fixes, or the nature of the transaction requires | A clear clause on sequence avoids the standoff |
| Contract Act, Section 54 | A party who fails to perform a promise that must come first cannot claim the other's performance | Defaulting on your own first step weakens your claim |
| TP Act, Section 55(1)(d) | Seller executes a proper conveyance on payment or tender of the price | Tender of the balance triggers the seller's duty to execute |
| TP Act, Section 55(5)(b) | Buyer pays or tenders the price at the time and place of completing the sale | Have the balance ready at the registration appointment |
Can the agreement decide who goes first?
Yes, and it should. Section 52 says that where the order in which reciprocal promises are to be performed is expressly fixed by the contract, they shall be performed in that order; where it is not, they shall be performed in the order which the nature of the transaction requires.
The illustrations show how the nature of a transaction can decide. In one, A contracts to build a house for B at a fixed price; A's promise to build must be performed before B's promise to pay. In another, a seller of stock need not deliver until the buyer gives the promised security, because the nature of the transaction requires the seller to have security first. For a property sale, the safest course is not to leave it to argument. Write the sequence into the agreement: for example, that the balance will be handed over at the sub-registrar's office against execution and presentation of the sale deed, or paid into a specified account at a specified stage.
What do the Transfer of Property Act duties add?
They tie each side's duty to the other's tender. Section 55(1)(d) says the seller is bound, on payment or tender of the amount due in respect of the price, to execute a proper conveyance of the property when the buyer tenders it to him for execution at a proper time and place. Section 55(5)(b) says the buyer is bound to pay or tender, at the time and place of completing the sale, the purchase money to the seller or such person as he directs.
The key word in both is tender. The law does not require the buyer to hand over the money and hope for the best; it requires the buyer to pay or tender it at the right time and place. Once the buyer has done that, the seller's duty to execute the conveyance is engaged.
How do I prove I was ready to pay if the deal falls through?
By making a proper offer of performance. Section 38 says that where a promisor has made an offer of performance to the promisee, and the offer has not been accepted, the promisor is not responsible for non-performance, nor does he thereby lose his rights under the contract. The offer must be unconditional; it must be made at a proper time and place, under circumstances that give the other person a reasonable opportunity of ascertaining that the person offering is able and willing there and then to do the whole of what he is bound to do.
In practice, that means turning up at the agreed time and place with the balance in a form the seller can verify, such as a demand draft or a sanctioned disbursement ready to be released, and keeping a record that you did. A dated letter or email confirming that you attended with the balance ready, and asking the seller to execute, is evidence of the offer the Act describes.
What if one side fails to do its part first?
Section 54 deals with a promise that must come first. It says that when a contract consists of reciprocal promises such that one cannot be performed, or its performance cannot be claimed, until the other has been performed, and the person who should perform first fails to do so, that person cannot claim performance of the reciprocal promise and must compensate the other party for any loss caused by the non-performance.
This is why buyers should check whether their agreement puts any obligation on them before registration day, such as paying a second instalment by a date or arranging the loan sanction letter. Missing your own first step can cost you the right to insist on the seller's. Our explainer on forfeiture and damages under the Contract Act covers what follows if one side breaches.
What else should change hands on the day?
Documents and possession. Our guide to what passes with a house under Section 8 explains the seller's duty to deliver title documents once the full price is paid, and to give possession when required. Agree in advance whether keys and original deeds will be handed over at the office or at the property, so that the last step does not become a second standoff.
How should a Bengaluru buyer plan registration day?
Whether you are completing a resale purchase in a project such as KNS Laurel on Sarjapur Road or buying an independent house, plan the sequence before you reach the counter.
- Write the order of payment and execution into the sale agreement, as Section 52 allows.
- Complete any obligations the agreement puts on you before registration day, so Section 54 does not work against you.
- Arrange the balance in a form the seller can verify at the office, such as a demand draft or a ready disbursement.
- Confirm the appointment time and place with the seller in writing.
- Attend on time with the balance and the draft deed, ready to perform in full.
- If the seller does not proceed, record in writing that you attended and offered the balance unconditionally.
- Agree in advance where keys and original title documents will be handed over.
Frequently asked questions
Does the seller have to sign the sale deed before I pay the balance?
Section 51 of the Indian Contract Act says that when a contract consists of reciprocal promises to be performed simultaneously, no promisor need perform unless the promisee is ready and willing to perform the reciprocal promise. If payment and signing are meant to happen together, each side can insist the other is ready.
What if the agreement says who must act first?
Section 52 of the Indian Contract Act says that where the order in which reciprocal promises are to be performed is expressly fixed by the contract, they shall be performed in that order. Where it is not fixed, they shall be performed in the order which the nature of the transaction requires.
What does the Transfer of Property Act say about paying and signing?
Section 55(1)(d) says the seller is bound, on payment or tender of the price, to execute a proper conveyance when the buyer tenders it at a proper time and place. Section 55(5)(b) says the buyer is bound to pay or tender the purchase money at the time and place of completing the sale.
How do I show I was ready to pay if the seller backs out?
Section 38 of the Indian Contract Act says that where a promisor makes an offer of performance that is not accepted, the promisor is not responsible for non-performance and does not lose rights under the contract. The offer must be unconditional and made at a proper time and place, showing the promisor is able and willing.
Last updated 2026-11-18. PropNewz Team.
Contact Us
Stay updated with latest news and new projects!
Tell us what you want, We'll do the rest.
Share your budget and where you're looking. An advisor who has actually walked the sites will shortlist a handful of RERA-registered projects and tell you which to skip.